Pretend Sales to Circumvent Homestead Protection

Homestead Protection Shield

In Texas, homestead protections are a powerful legal shield designed to prevent homeowners from losing their primary residence to creditors. However, some unscrupulous lenders have attempted to find creative ways to get around these protections, often through "pretend sales" and other complex documents. These schemes are designed to give lenders a claim on a homesteaded property that they would not otherwise have. Texas law has very strong homestead protections because the state wants to protect people from losing their homes.

What Are Homestead Protections?

Homestead protections in Texas shield a homeowner’s primary residence from a lien being placed on it and subsequently being sold to satisfy that lien. While there are some exceptions, known as the "magic eight," that allow for the forced sale of a homestead (such as for purchase money loans, home equity loans, refinance loans, or taxes), the law generally prevents lenders from using a homestead as collateral for other types of loans, especially business loans.

Lenders' Creative Tactics

Lenders have devised various strategies to try and circumvent these homestead laws. These schemes often involve having the homeowner engage in a "pretend sale" of the property. Common tactics include:

  1. Placing the property in an LLC: The lender might ask the homeowner to transfer their home's title to an LLC, which would then be used as collateral for a loan.
  2. Deeding the property over to the lender: In some cases, a lender may ask the homeowner to deed the property directly to them as a condition of the loan.
  3. Option Contracts: A particularly creative and complex example involves an option contract. In this scenario, if the borrower defaults on a promissory note, the lender has the option to purchase the house at a discounted price. This is essentially a creative way to force a sale of the homesteaded property.

The Legal Reality for Lenders and Borrowers

For lenders, it is crucial to understand that homestead property is considered "sacred" in Texas. The courts have generally frowned upon attempts to collateralize a homestead outside of the "magic eight" exceptions. Any creative document or contract designed to skirt homestead laws will likely be invalid. For borrowers, while this information may be tempting to use in a predatory manner, it is important to avoid using your homestead as collateral in any capacity that falls outside the legally recognized exceptions. The law is designed to protect you, and engaging in these types of transactions can lead to complex legal issues down the road.

All information provided on Silblawfirm.com (hereinafter "website") is provided for informational purposes only, and is not intended to be used for legal advice. Users of this website should not take any actions or refrain from taking any actions based upon content or information on this website. Users of this site should contact a licensed Texas attorney for a full and complete review of their legal issues.