When it comes to emotional support animals (ESAs) in rental properties, landlords in Texas face a unique set of legal challenges. Specifically, many landlords wonder whether they can deny certain breeds, such as Pit Bulls or Dobermans, especially when there are concerns about safety. The reality is that emotional support animals are protected by federal law, and landlords have limited grounds to refuse them. Here’s a breakdown of the legal landscape regarding emotional support animals and how landlords should navigate this delicate situation.
Federal Laws on Emotional Support Animals
The Fair Housing Act (FHA) governs how landlords should handle emotional support animals. Under the FHA, individuals with disabilities are entitled to reasonable accommodations, which may include allowing an emotional support animal, regardless of the landlord's typical pet policy. The FHA defines an emotional support animal as an animal that provides therapeutic benefits to individuals with a diagnosed mental or emotional disorder. Importantly, these animals are not considered pets, and thus, they are exempt from pet deposits and pet rent fees.
Can You Deny an Emotional Support Animal Based on Breed?
One of the most common concerns for landlords is whether they can deny an emotional support animal based on its breed. In Texas, as in many states, landlords cannot deny an ESA solely because of its breed, even if the animal is commonly associated with aggressive tendencies, such as Pit Bulls, Dobermans, or German shepherds. Once a tenant provides documentation supporting their need for an ESA, such as a letter from a licensed mental health professional, the landlord is required to make a reasonable accommodation for the tenant’s request.
Reasonable Accommodation Exceptions
While landlords are generally required to accommodate emotional support animals, there are some exceptions. The key consideration is whether the animal poses a direct threat to the health or safety of others or would cause significant damage to the property. For example, if the specific animal (regardless of its breed) has a history of aggressive behavior, landlords may have a valid reason to deny the ESA request. However, these cases must be based on individual assessments rather than breed alone.
Restrictions on Questions Landlords Can Ask
Landlords may be concerned about the legitimacy of ESA documentation, especially if the animal is of a breed they consider high-risk. However, the FHA and other laws limit the types of questions landlords can ask regarding the tenant’s disability or need for an ESA. Due to privacy laws, such as HIPAA, landlords cannot inquire about the specifics of the tenant’s medical condition. Landlords are only allowed to ask for documentation confirming the tenant’s need for the emotional support animal and cannot request details about the tenant’s diagnosis or medical history.
No Pet Deposits or Fees Allowed
Another point that often catches landlords off-guard is that emotional support animals are not subject to pet deposits or monthly pet rent. Since ESAs are not considered pets under the law, landlords are prohibited from charging extra fees for their accommodation. However, landlords may still hold tenants responsible for any damages caused by the emotional support animal, just as they would for any other type of property damage.
Conclusion
In summary, landlords in Texas must navigate the legal framework surrounding emotional support animals carefully. While certain concerns may arise, especially regarding specific breeds or past behaviors, federal law mandates that landlords generally must make reasonable accommodations for emotional support animals. Denying a tenant’s ESA request based solely on breed could expose a landlord to legal action under the Fair Housing Act.
All information provided on Silblawfirm.com (hereinafter "website") is provided for informational purposes only, and is not intended to be used for legal advice. Users of this website should not take any actions or refrain from taking any actions based upon content or information on this website. Users of this site should contact a licensed Texas attorney for a full and complete review of their legal issues.